A tale of two
strikes
The strikes at Manesar and Chakan point to a common
problem: outdated labour laws.
The tame end to a 50-day labour stir at Bajaj
Auto’s Chakan plant in Maharashtra is a study in contrast to the two rounds of
strikes at Maruti Suzuki’s Manesar unit near Delhi in 2011 and 2012, when the
Japanese carmaker had to meet some of the workers’ key demands. What this
captures is the changed economic situation on the ground. In 2012, the economic
slowdown had not started to bite and sales of cars — more so the diesel sedans
that the Manesar factory was producing — were buoyant. The workers chose the
‘right’ time to strike and, at the end of it, Maruti Suzuki was forced to
accept a 50 per cent wage increase and a phased programme of regularising all
contract workers undertaking core manufacturing functions.
The workers in Chakan, in contrast, got both their
timing as well as cause wrong. The most audacious of their demands was for all
the plant’s 900 workers to be given 500 shares of Bajaj Auto at Re. 1 each, as
against the ruling stock price of Rs 1800 when the strike began on June 25. It
is difficult to see company managements agreeing to such a demand even in good
times. But where the labour union really went wrong was in ignoring the
intensity of the current slowdown. The fact that two-wheeler sales have been
declining and the auto industry as a whole is going through a protracted slump
didn’t figure in its calculations. So unlike Maruti Suzuki in 2012, the
management at Bajaj Auto followed a strategy of simply tiring the workers out
and keeping the factory running using trainees who were not a part of the
union. Once they realised their weakened bargaining power, the workers
eventually decided to call off their strike without any of their demands —
including instituting a new wage agreement — met.
The contrasting stories, however, highlight a
common problem: outdated labour laws. Unions are right to demand an end to
hiring workers on a contract/trainee basis and paying them less than half of
what the regular workforce gets for the same work. But the blame here lies with
the Industrial Disputes Act that does not allow companies hiring more than 100
workers to retrench even in downturns without government permission (which is
seldom given). Therefore, firms prefer maintaining the permanent workforce at a
bare minimum and hire the rest on contract depending on the ebbs and flows of
the business cycle. India needs labour reforms that require companies to keep
all workers engaged in core operations on their regular rolls, while entitling
them to uniform work-linked wages, provident fund and other benefits. This
should be combined with the flexibility to lay off, subject to reasonable
advance notice and payment of all statutory dues.
(This article was published on August 16, 2013)