Triple Bottom line – An
emerging approach to Business Strategy
-
P.Vijay
Kumar
If
there are to be problems, may they come during my life-time so that I can
resolve them and give my children the chance of a good life - Kenyan proverb
ABSTRACT
In the process of making profits, the
Corporates are consuming the valuable Natural Resources indiscriminately as we
have seen recently in the case of Mining Mafia in the State of Karnataka. Many
industries are overdrawing Water from the Earth and are also polluting Water
Sources like rivers and canals, as was evident in the Coca Cola Case in the
State of Kerala. They also release Green House Gases into the atmosphere, which
is causing Global Warming leading to Climate Change and its wider impact on the
Humankind. Thus the industrial activity and the human actions are endangering
the Planet, and are making the people suffer immensely. This has given rise to
the need for protecting the Planet and People while making Profits-the concept
of Triple Bottom line Approach (TBL) i.e. balancing economic prosperity,
environmental quality and social justice.
This article deals with the Concept of TBL, how
the Corporates measure and manage their impacts on the economic, environmental
and social fronts, how they engage with their Stakeholders, how companies
achieve their business goals through the integration of economic, environmental
and social growth opportunities into their business strategies. This also
portrays some of the Indian Corporates who are excelling in their Business,
while complementing the needs of the Society and Protecting the Environment and
are contributing their part to the Sustainable Development.
INTRODUCTION
Business of Business
is Business, said Milton Friedman. A business organisation is intended to do
some Business activity and obtain profit. If a business is unable to make a profit,
it is a drain on the Society. Traditionally, therefore, the measure of success
of a business is profit - a return on investment, and shareholder value.
In the process of making profits, the Corporates are consuming the valuable Natural Resources indiscriminately as we have seen recently in the case of Mining Mafia in the State of Karnataka. Many industries are overdrawing Water from the Earth and are also polluting Water Sources like Water tables, rivers and canals, as was evident in the Coca Cola Case in the State of Kerala. Industries also release Green House Gases into the atmosphere, which is causing Global Warming, leading to Climate Change and its wider impact on the Humankind. Thus the industrial activity and the human actions are endangering the Planet, and are making the people suffer immensely. This has given rise to the need for protecting the Planet and People while making Profits - the concept of Triple Bottom line Approach (TBL) i.e. balancing economic prosperity, environmental quality and social justice.
The traditional measure of
corporate success is profit - the “bottom line” of the profit and loss account.
The second is the bottom line of a company’s “people” account- a measure of how
socially responsible an organisation has been in its operations. The third is
the bottom line of the company’s “planet” account- a measure of how
environmentally responsible it has been. The triple bottom line (TBL) thus
consists of three Ps: Profit, People and Planet.
It aims to measure the financial, social and environmental performance of the
corporation over a period of time. Only a company that produces a TBL is taking
account of the full cost involved in doing business.
Andrew Savitz (2006)2
defines TBL as a method that "captures the essence of sustainability by
measuring the impact of an organization's activities on the world ... including
both its profitability and shareholder values and its social, human and
environmental capital”. The trick isn't defining TBL. The trick is
measuring it. (Timothy F. Slaper, 2011).
TBL approach to business implies that:
a) Corporate
profit needs to be analysed in conjunction with social prosperity and Environment
protection.
b) Stakeholders
in a business are not just the company’s shareholders. All those who impact or
impacted by the Business should be regarded equally.
c) Sustainable
development leads to economic sustainability.
The Need for TBL
The existence of a Business organisation
is interconnected with the Society in which it is operating, which is known as
“license to operate”. This does not refer to any specific document
or permit required by law. Rather, it
refers to society’s acceptance of the organization and its willingness to let
the business continue operating. Companies gain and maintain their licenses to
operate by providing value to the community. Value refers to more than just
economic development; it also encompasses environmental protection and social
equity. Corporations believe that
licence to operate is not only from regulators but also from the community they
operate.
Contents of TBL Dimensions
Economic Measures
Economic variables deal with the bottom line
and the flow of money. It comprises of income or expenditures, taxes, business
climate, Contribution to exchequer etc.
The economic Measures sometimes are equated
with the Financial Performance measures like profit, enhancement of shareholder
value etc.
Environmental Measures
Environmental variables represent measurements of
natural resources and reflect potential impact on environmental viability. It includes
usage of natural resources, Release of Green House Gases, Electricity
consumption, Fossil fuel consumption, Water use and water pollution, Solid
waste and Hazardous waste management, Change in land use/land cover etc.
Corporates having long-range initiatives for each
of the environmental variables would help organizations identify the impacts a
project or policy would have on the area.
Social Measures
Social variables refer to social dimensions of a
community or region. The Social Measures include Education facilities, Literacy
rate, Employment opportunities, Women in employment, Reduction of poverty, Health-Lifestyle
and life expectancy, property value, development of infrastructure like roads,
schools etc. Measuring social performance helps improve social performance, and
firms with better social performance tend to be more profitable in the
long-run. Ex. What social benefit is being brought to XYZ village?
Challenges, in
putting the TBL into practice
Putting the TBL into practice is not as easy
that it would appear. Some of the challenges include measurement of the
performance of a corporate in each of the three categories, finding applicable
data and calculating a project or policy's contribution to sustainability.
A company
considers its financial soundness as vital and this can be easily tracked by
totaling a company’s total expenses to a company’s total income. But tracking the Social and Environment
Performance is quite difficult. With finances, we can identify a monetary value
to calculate costs and revenues. With social and environmental measures,
however, the currency is much more abstract, making it difficult to obtain. Norman
and MacDonald3 in their 2004 paper entitled, "Getting to the Bottom of the 'Triple Bottom Line'"
mention this difficulty and suggest it may even be impossible to quantify or
track these two criteria in an objective manner. However, while we may not be
able to calculate the measures of social and environmental performance clearly,
we can nonetheless track it. Many agencies have come up with frameworks to
measure triple bottom-line, and are improving their frameworks, on a continuous
basis. Many progressive organisations abroad, like AT&T, Dow Chemicals,
Shell, and British Telecom, Delloit etc, and Indian organisations like TATAs,
ITC, ACC, ONGC, Punj Lloyd etc have used these frameworks and have proved that social
and environmental measures can be tracked.
The TBL
framework allows organizations to evaluate the ramifications of their decisions
from a truly long-run perspective. What is to be remembered is that, in the
measurement of concerns and performance relating to people and planet, we
should keep in mind is, that unlike profit, these things do not add up or
reduce to some specific value.
There is no universal standard method for calculating
the TBL. Neither is there a universally accepted standard for the measures that
comprise each of the three TBL categories. This can be viewed as a strength
because it allows a user to adapt the general framework to the needs of
different entities (businesses or nonprofits), different projects or Sectors
(infrastructure, Mining, Oil and Gas, investment or educational programs), or
different geographic boundaries (a city, region or country).
TBL IN PRACTICE
Despite the inherent weakness in the TBL framework enumerated herein,
the TBL is widely being implemented in organisations across the Globe.
Agencies like The Dow Jones Sustainability Group Index (DJSGI), SustainAbility
(SA8000), Accountability (AA1000), GRI (G3 and G3.1), UNGC (COP) OECD MNE
Guidelines, IFC Guidelines etc. and ISO-26000, have brought out frameworks to
measure the Triple Bottom Line of Organisations. The GRI provides the world’s
most comprehensive framework for producing sustainability reports, and is the
most popular metrics followed by most organisations world over to report their
non-financial performance. The GRI Sustainability Reporting Guidelines enable
large and small companies, non-profit organizations and government bodies
worldwide to assess their sustainability performance and disclose the results
in a similar way to financial reporting. Transparency through reporting on
economic, environmental and social factors drives the sustainability of
individual organizations and, ultimately, the global economy.
While the non-financial Reporting is widely followed, the concept of integrated
reporting is also gaining ground, where organisations release a Combined Report
covering both Financial and Non-financial performance, which makes things
easier for the Corporates to transparently report their performance.
The Corporates are expected to find ways
to be part of the solution to the world’s environmental and social problems.
The best companies are finding ways to turn this responsibility into
opportunity. When business and societal interests overlap, everyone wins. Today,
leading manufacturers are minimising pollution (Mining, Cement, Power industry),
cutting waste and trimming resource consumption, designing environmentally safe
products(diesel/solar versions of Cars), energy efficient machinery(Five star
rated machines like ACs, Electrical appliances) and producing products with
fewer harmful chemicals(Toys, Woolens) etc. Reduce, reuse, recycle is the new
business mantra. And the triple bottom line is replacing purely economic
metrics.
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
The performance of organisations following
the TBL approach results in to the new way of Corporate Success, known as
Sustainable Development.
Sustainable Development is one that 'meets the
needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to
meet their own needs' (Brundtland 1987 p. 8) This definition is also endorsed
by the (World Commission on Environment and Development (1987). Sustainability
cannot be achieved without addressing social justice issues and humane
consideration toward the whole community of life (University Leaders for a
Sustainable Future 2007). Hence, sustainability is an evolving paradigm for
planning and decision-making, which requires a basic understanding of the
interconnections and interdependency among ecological, economic, and social systems
(Kemp, Parto & Gibson 2005; Munier 2005; Schmuck & Schultz 2002). These
three independent dimensions or pillars of sustainability - ecological
preservation, social wellbeing for all members of society and economic
viability - represent the widely recognized triple bottom line (Mawhinney
2002).
Mike Fraser(2011)
defines Sustainability as the “ability to endure”. It’s about personal and
corporate activity and behavior that enables society and its members to a) Meet
or exceed their current needs, b) Preserve or improve biodiversity and natural
ecosystems, c) Plan and act in a manner
that maintains this balance indefinitely.
N. R.
Narayana Murthy, Chairman Emeritus, Infosys, in one of his speeches, mentioned
that “Sustainability is when you practice Fairness, Transparency, and Accountability
towards all Stakeholders, through which you will maximize shareholder value”.
For businesses,
sustainability is a powerful and defining idea. A sustainable business corporation
is one that creates profit for its shareholders while protecting the
environment and improving the lives of those with whom it interacts. It
operates so that its business interests and the interests of the environment
and society intersect. Sustainable business stands an excellent chance of being
more successful tomorrow than it is today, and remaining successful, not just
for months or even years, but for decades or generations.
INDIAN SCENARIO
The TBL based Sustainable
Development is practiced by major Corporates, both in the Private and Public
Sectors, like TATAs, ITC, ACC, ONGC, Punj Lloyd, Jubiliant Organosis, GAIL,
BPCL, etc., in social and ethical accounting, auditing and reporting. According
the GRI Reports List (1 January to 31 December 2010), 23 Indian Corporates from
India that reported under GRI. More and
more organisations are joining the list every year.
TBL
is being increasingly recognised in
India, and many companies are working on setting up governance, management and
reporting systems for environmental, social and economic performance. Birla
group chief Kumaramangalam Birla, in a PwC report, said he has adopted a TBL
approach to management where accountability lies at the heart of corporate
responsibility, as it involves factoring holistically the interests of all
stakeholders - shareholders, customers, employees and the community at large.
Dr. RK Pachauri says a company’s behaviour can well reflect on its reputation.
In a market where there is little to distinguish between products, companies
perceived as more responsible, are beginning to score higher in the battle for
the consumer’s mind, heart and wallet.
In
future, TBL will only increase in significance for Indian companies as a
majority of companies are striving to attain operational sustainability. This
may be due to global pressures and by recognising its significance to their
long-term growth. Companies like ACC are doing this at the instance of their
International Holding companies.
TBL CASE STUDY - ITC
To cite a specific Case, the ITC example of the TBL is exemplary.
ITC is a 100 year old company,
the leading FMCG marketer in India, the second largest Hotel chain, the clear
market leader in the Indian Paperboard and Packaging industry, and the country’s
foremost Agri-business player.
ITC reports its performance annually and the current Report is for the
period from April 1, 2010 to March 31, 2011. The Sustainability Report 2011 is
ITC’s eighth Sustainability Report. It conforms to GRI G3 guidelines. This
Report reflects material issues, which have significant economic, environmental
and social impacts that can substantially influence the assessments or
decisions of the stakeholders.
The highlights of the Sustainability Report 20114 (TBL
Report) are:
ECONOMIC Performance of ITC
· Progressive
investment in multiple drivers of growth (encompassing FMCG, Paperboards &
Packaging, Agri Business, Hotels and Information Technology).
· Total
Shareholder Returns has grown 26% over the last 15 years.
· Market
capitalisation increased 25 folds. Market Capitalisation which stood at 5,570
Crores in1996, has multiplied to cross Rs.1,40,400 Crores. ITC is amongst the
top 10 private sector companies in terms of market capitalisation.
· Gross
turnover increased by 16.50% over 2009-10.
· Taxes
paid increased by16%.
· Encourages
local employment in the workforce in manufacturing and hotels, depending on the
availability of the required skills.
· ITC
is amongst the top 10 Global Consumer goods companies, in terms of sustainable shareholder
Value creation for the period 2005-2009
ENVIRONMENTAL Performance of ITC
· 'Carbon
Positive' Six years in a row (Carbon sequestering / storing twice the amount of
CO2, that the Company emits).
· 'Water
Positive' for Nine consecutive years. (Creating three times more rainwater
harvesting potential than ITC's net consumption).
· ’Waste
Recycling Positive’ for the last Four years. 100% recycling. Creating
Wealth out of Waste–use of post consumer waste as raw material.
· Nearly
35% of total energy consumed is from renewable sources.
· ITC
Royal Gardenia and ITC Green Centre are two of the world's largest LEED
Platinum rated green buildings.
· Environment,
Health and Safety Management Systems in ITC conform to international standards.
· In
2009-2010, ITC Units consumed 21,455 Terra Joules (TJ) of energy, which is
11.2% higher than the energy utilised in the previous year. (19,284 TJ in
2008-2009). This is due to significant growth in almost all businesses.
· Substantially
improved utilisation of carbon neutral fuels, such as black liquor and deoiled
bran in the Paperboards and Specialty Papers business.
· Increased
utilisation of renewable energy, due to the commissioning of a 6MW wind power
plant (commissioned September 2009) in Maharashtra for the Hotels business
& a 90 TPH biomass fired boiler (commissioned February 2010) at the
Bhadrachalam Paperboards and Specialty Papers Unit.
· Monitoring
combustion efficiencies to achieve lower specific emissions
SOCIAL Performance of ITC
· ITC's
businesses generate livelihoods for over 5 million people.
· ITC's
globally recognised e-Choupal initiative is the world's largest rural digital
infrastructure benefitting over 5 million farmers.
· ITC's
Social and Farm Forestry initiative has greened over 1,14,000 hectares, creating an estimated 51 million
person-days of employment. ITC's Watershed Development initiative brings
precious water to over 54,000 hectares of dry-lands and moisture-stressed
areas.
· ITC's
Sustainable Community Development initiatives include women's empowerment,
supplementary education and integrated animal husbandry programmes.
· The manufacturing Units have been Hazard
Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) certified, and or certified under
ISO 9001, ISO/ IEC 17025, ISO 27001 frameworks.
· Strong focus on occupational health and safety.
· Progressing towards zero accidents.
· Livestock
Development Initiatives.
·
Building skills and social infrastructure
through: Primary Education, Health &
Sanitation.
· Women Empowerment & Gender Equality.
· ITC's
strategy has been to create a holistic Triple Bottom Line approach that focuses
on building sustainable livelihoods.
Sustainability and sustainable development are integral to ITC's ethos and find expression in their commitment to enhancing the Triple Bottom Line dimensions of building economic, social and environmental capital. The interventions of ITC in Agriculture, Social Forestry and provision of Sustainable Livelihoods; Carbon positive, Water positive and Waste recycling Positive initiatives; promotion of Indian culture, the most popular e-Choupal initiative, production and utilisation of alternative sources of energy etc are commendable and worth emulation by the Corporates in India
The challenges that businesses are now facing
are newer and different in nature. The conventional challenges are challenge of
growing profits, revenues and markets in the face of increasing competition.
The new challenges centre on securing a ‘social license to operate’, ensuring
long term sustenance, generating a long term value and creating a win-win
between business, society and the environment (TBL). In the midst of these
transformational changes, it is imperative for the Indian business to perform
not only financially but also to be good corporate citizens, and TBL based
Sustainable Development is the Way Forward!
References
1. Elkington, J., “Cannibals with Forks: the Triple
Bottom Line of 21st Century Business”, Capstone, 1997
2.
Savitz, A.W. and Weber, K., “The Triple Bottom
Line: How Today’s Best-Run Companies Are Achieving Economic, Social and
Environmental Success—and How You Can Too”, Jossey-Bass, 2006
5.
John Elington, "Towards the Sustainable
Corporation: Win-Win-Win Business Strategies for Sustainable Development,"
California Management Review 36, no. 2 (1994): 90–100.
6. http://www.financialexpress.com/news/we-lay-a-lot-of-stress-on-triple-bottomline/173286/0‘We
lay a lot of stress on triple bottom-line’ , Aug 06, 2006
Accounting For A Triple Bottom Line, Dec 02, 2002.
8.
Shivani Puri: Triple bottom line approach should
be considered. F.E. Mar 14, 2011
No comments:
Post a Comment