Thursday, July 26, 2012

CASE STUDIES IN HR/IR

CASE Studies in HR/IR  1 26.7.2012



Industrial Relations Challenges and Issues - A Case Study
P.Vijay Kumar, Associate Professor,
Department of Management Studies, GIET

A Ceramic Factory, a Public Limited Company, established in 1983 with Italian Collaboration, is the largest manufacturer and exporter of ceramic tiles in India.  It has a daily production capacity of 44,000 sq.m. It has two modern manufacturing facilities and offices in all metros and two tier cities in addition to 700 dealers across India. The factory has some ancillary units.
About 5 years ago, a Dubai based MNC started 50 ceramic units all over the country. Since then the factory’s profits have come down and the company has been suffering losses during the last six quarters, with accumulated losses of Rs 35 crore, especially as the unit has been operating at 50 to 60 per cent of its capacity. The company has a debt burden of around Rs 80 crore as term loans and around Rs 35 crore as working capital. The Factory has an insurance cover of around Rs 500 crore.
At the factory and ancillary units, there are about 2000 contract workers doing the works such as cleaning and loading, packing, and actual manufacturing process and assembly line. The skill levels range from the unskilled to the highly skilled.
The employees started a Union in 1987 and 1989, but they disappeared shortly after formation. A new Union was formed January 2011. The Union fought with the Management and obtained facilities like dearness allowance, clean drinking water, ambulance facility, safety equipment such as safety shoes, masks etc, 8 hours work, canteen facility etc. The highest wages received by a highly skilled worker is about Rs.9000/ month. The lowest paid casual labour, even after 15 years of service in the company were getting only Rs. 1800/ month, which were raised to Rs.3000, after a strike. The Management attempted to victimise the Leader and other office bearers of the Union and dismissed the Union Leader in August2011, in an unfair enquiry. 
The workers continued to demand Increase in wages, Payment of Bonus, Reinstatement of terminated employees, and Regularization of workers with more than 15 years of service with the company etc. Conciliation is pending on these demands.
The management, in informal discussions with the workers, agreed to pay Rs. 5000/- as bonus and also increase the increment amount on the condition that the production is increased from the current rate of 28000 sq.m/day, to 32000 sq. m/day. Within 15 days the workers achieved 36000sq.m./day. They asked for the wage rise of Rs.2500/ worker, but the management went back, and threatened the workers against raising any more demands and to create fear in their minds, they also suspended 5 of their union’s office bearers/active members.
The Incident
On 02/01/12 the management of Cement Factory wanted the workers to sign an Undertaking and only those who signed the undertaking were allowed to work. Some 650 workers who were members of the union refused to sign it while 300 workers who were not union members signed it and went into the factory. Union members denied entry into factory. The Union continued the struggle. The management got an injunction order from the High Court at Chennai, preventing the workers from gathering within 200 meters of the factory.
On 27/01/12, the Union Leader, together with about 50 workers went near the factory, but about 300 meters away from the gate, appealing to some employees to refrain from going to work and to join them in the struggle.  The management informed the police and arrested the Leader and other active workers. In the Police Station, the Leader complained of chest pain and he died on way to the hospital.
On hearing the news of the death of the Union leader workers thronged the Police Station and the Police resorted to Firing, resulting in injuries to some workmen. Workers burst out in anger and rushed towards the factory and burnt the vehicles, damaged the property and destroyed the machinery in the factory. They also attacked the President of the factory and brutally injured him and he succumbed to the injuries.
The company suffered crippling losses amounting to Rs 600 crores. The cost of relocating the unit would be about Rs 700 crore.
Factory Lock out
31st Jan, 2012 the management declared a lock-out without giving any notice to the workers. The lock-out has declared on the grounds that the workers resorted to illegal strike and the production has come to a standstill and machinery was destroyed in arson. The employees lost their livelihood, the management suffered a huge loss and the nation lost the opportunities of productive activity and employment. The union and political parties demand to restart the factory.
Questions for Discussion 
1)    Who is responsible for the incident?
2)    Should the Union take Law into their hands?
3)    Is the management right in declaring a lock-out?
4)    Should the Govt. take steps to reopen the industry to provide employment to the workers?
5)    What preventive measures should be taken by management, union and by government to prevent recurrence of such situations? 

No comments: